The Best Pizza Restaurant In Kihei Maui

Ronda Kitts

Easy five stars! I regularly go here for dinner, or a beer and a bite while running Kihei errands. As far as food goes, their pizza is FANTASTIC; reminds me of my childhood pizza place l'd go to growing up. I've also had their philly cheese steaks and wings which are awesome. Plus they make their own ranch! | put it ... on everything. Staff is always friendly and personable, and the atmosphere is warm and welcoming! Highly recommend Read More

Roy Actual

Very friendly staff. Comfortable and clean sturdy picnic style tables. Counter/ bar service available. Fun and lively atmosphere with several high mounted television monitors. Clean and comfortable restrooms. The pizzas are made to order. Great crust. Several specialty pizzas and a build-your-own option. ... Sandwiches made with fresh ingredients. Check QR menu for selection and prices. Complete bar with beer and spirits. Plenty of free parking in front of the location and on an adjacent street. Call to confirm hours or order ahead. Take out available. Read More

FRANCISCO LOPEZ

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Pizza Madness in Kihei is the real deal! Whether you’re visiting Maui or lucky enough to live here, this spot is a must. The dough is incredible, the pizza is always spot-on, and the hot wings are some of the best around. Their salads are huge and super fresh — definitely not your average side salad. The ... atmosphere is just as good as the food. Affordable prices, comfy picnic-bench seating, and really fun local-style art (sharks and fish chomping down on pizza!) give the place such a cool Maui vibe. It’s one of those rare spots that tourists discover and rave about, but locals keep coming back to because it’s consistently awesome. Love this place! 🍕🔥 Read More

Will Ellis

Incredibly delicious! The best pizza I’ve had in a really long time. Keno was a fantastic server and shared everything is made fresh daily - never frozen. It’s tried & true which shows in the quality of pizza. We definitely recommend

Josie L

Great food & very friendly staff. One of our best dining experiences on Maui! Happy hour wings are A+++. Also shared a 1/2 meat lovers and half bbq chicken pizza and as a Chicago transplant, I can honestly say this is the best pizza we've had anywhere in a very long time. Good beer selection served ice cold. ... Delicious ice cream cookie sandwiches. Ordered the cinnamon bites to go and they are addictive!! Lastly, the service from Keno was phenomenal! His Aloha welcoming spirit made for a memorable dining experience. We highly recommend this gem of a restaurant. Read More

J L

I was visiting friends in Kihei from Chicago and this was our first stop from the airport. The pizza was just as amazing as in Chicago. The pizza crust was the perfect texture, delicious sauce and cheese blend, beautiful location, and the atmosphere was relaxing. Natalie, Keno, & Max were amazing and made us feel ... like family. I was shocked at the generous size of their pizzas and their rewards program to earn a free pizza. Thank you! Read More

Frank Lopez

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Pizza Madness – Kihei’s Slice of Magic! 🍕✨ If you’re in Kihei, you have to stop at Pizza Madness! The food is incredible, the atmosphere is fun and lively, and Fridays are pure magic — literally! 🎩🍕 George performs live magic shows on Friday nights, making dinner here an experience you won’t forget. The ... pizza is some of the best on Maui — crispy crust, loaded toppings, and bursting with flavor. The Kirk Special is one of my all-time favorites! 🙌 They’ve also got beer, wine, and cocktails to make your meal complete. Whether you’re coming for the pizza, the vibes, or the Friday night show — you’ll leave smiling and full. Gotta come to Kihei for this pie! 🍕🔥 #PizzaMadness #KiheiEats #MauiFoodie #FridayNightMagic #SupportLocal Read More